2020 REVIEWS FROM LETTERBOXD.COM

  • Hollywood

    Hollywood

    ★★★

    Ryan Murphy's and Ian Bannan's seven part Netflix mini-series is a somewhat predictable alternate history of the late-1940's Hollywood studio system. It centers on a studio (Paramount, a studio I worked at in the 1960s, stands in for the fictitious Ace Studios), where the widow of the former mogul takes a chance on making a film about a troubled black actress played by an African-American actress who is actually given a groundbreaking starring role, with a script written by a gay African-American man, and with roles for LGBs proudly coming out, and a real Asian actress...not one played by a Caucasian in makeup.

    This is revisionist reality of a Hollywood dream factory that didn't exist then, and even today hardly exists. Still, despite its often saccharin sweetness, and wish fulfillment fantasy story, the fine cast and superb production design make the series well worth watching. Just don't think it came close to presenting a reality, despite depicting several real Hollywood celebrities (Rock Hudson and his predatory agent Henry Willson, Anna May Wong, and Hattie McDaniel among others are major characters.) I both cringed and cried at times watching this series. But I was never bored.

  • Circus of Books

    Circus of Books

    ★★★½

    The Masons were an ordinary L.A. Jewish family. Barry, the dad, had been a UCLA film student in the early 1960s, a special effects technician in the 1970s (both of these oddly mirrored my own experiences...however I don't recall him at all), a successful inventor, and finally co-owner with his wife of three notorious gay bookstores from 1982 to 2019. Karen, the mom, raised three kids, was active in Conservative Jewish circles, and secretly became a queen of the gay porn trade, purveyor of gay pornography that was shipped nationwide. Ultimately their venture entailed encounters with the federal courts over restrictive pornography laws; and Barry risked prison as a result of their activities.

    Their story is told by their grown daughter, Rachel: film maker and artist (and incidentally the singer-songwriter of a superb song which played over the end credits). The film utilizes home movies and, over time, video footage shot with increasingly more sophisticated equipment to document the history of this odd, and somehow endearing family and their gay pornography and sex paraphernalia stocked local bookstores "Circus of Books."

    The film is a fascinating look into the family, the stores, the employees, and importantly the history of gay liberation in Los Angeles. It manages to organize decades worth of material into a cohesive and often moving narrative, roughly chronological but with eccentric continuity jumps. I can't deny that my own life experiences, which dovetail in several ways with the Mason's, affected my involvement with the film. But bottom line: this is an important documentary in the ongoing process of uncovering the hidden history of gay life and culture in the U.S.

  • Devs

    Devs

    ★★★★½

    This addendum is being written by a simulation of me in the future (4/16), brought to life by the "Devs" machine algorithm. My message is that the series ended just as strangely and wonderfully as the God machine predicted from the beginning. Nice job, Alex Garland. Now back to the original review from 4/8...

    With one episode to go (coming 4/16), this has been the most fascinating of recent streaming dramas...no surprise since creator Alex Garland is a superbly visionary film maker. I don't write reviews of productions I have not completed...so my review has to wait until next week. In the meantime, catch this F/X on HULU series. It's fascinating and challenging...long form sci-fi at its best.

  • Head Burst

    Head Burst

    ★★★★

    I was in the midst of writing a review of this brave and difficult German film about Markus, a guilt ridden, 30-something, boy-lover pedophile (surely one of the few totally taboo subjects in filmdom), when my computer suddenly went "blue-screen of death" and ate the almost finished piece. I take this as a hint that I wasn't meant to write this review. So, the great German actor, Max Riemelt, and his courageous job of truthfully portraying such a tragic character will have to go unsung. To be sure, Markus never actually acts on his urges in the film. The script makes it clear that it is about his lonely struggle against a proclivity that is beyond the control of those who suffer from it. I've rarely encountered a film that engendered such a feeling of angst and thwarted sympathy for its protagonist. Watch it for Riemelt's performance. But be prepared for the kind of emotional turmoil that made me pause for a break three times while watching the video.

    Personal note: at age 78, with underlying health issues, I'm voluntarily under home sequester for the duration of the pandemic. Normally, I prefer to watch films on the big screen and utilize internet and streaming services for long-form, serialized TV dramas. I wish more of these were considered subjects for letterboxd reviews. Bottom line: my reviews of feature films here will be rare for a while.

  • The Thing About Harry

    The Thing About Harry

    ★★★★

    The predominately YA cable channel "Freeform," under its current Disney-TV ownership, has become a surprisingly gay accepting venue. The Thing About Harry is a new gay (or rather poly-) romantic comedy about two post-college aged men who were antagonists over sexual identity in high-school, and who reconnect with a frequently amusing on-again, off-again fairy-tale (to coin a phrase) relationship. I have a weak spot for rom-coms to begin with; and I'm predisposed to prefer that rare species of gay rom-com. And this one didn't disappoint.

    What worked: the palpable chemistry between the three lead actors. Sam (an authentic, skillfully comic performance by Jake Borelli) is the "out" quipster, hesitant to cross the friend/lover barrier. Harry (Niko Terho) is convincing as the attractive, polysexual boy-toy-with-brains type. And completing the inevitable triangle is Stasia (Britt Baron), the straight girl, f**hag best friend. Another factor in the film's favor: the script by actor/auteur Peter Paige who shows a real talent for clever repartée and effective farce.

    What didn't work as well: we've seen this before, sort of with Love, Simon, although the genre hasn't really been overworked by Hollywood. And the "happy, romantic ending" for all involved is almost too sweet to be the realistic conclusion of the situations set up earlier in the film.

    Nevertheless, this is a fine example of gay positive television that deserves to be noticed and appreciated. I think it can be seen on HULU.

  • How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World

    How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World

    ★★★

    This was my last film to watch before voting for the Oscars tonight. Once again I've seen every nominated film, as I have since 1975. But this one I watched on video, which was undoubtedly a mistake as it surely would have had a greater impact on the big screen. The 3D animated visual effects were spectacular, rivaling last year's Spider-Verse (the best ever) in complexity and beauty. And the vocal acting was fine. However I was never quite able to care about the conflict-filled story; and the other technical credits, such as musical score, and character animation (human and dragon) were sub-par for the genre.

  • Julia Sweeney - Letting Go of God

    Julia Sweeney – Letting Go of God

    ★★★★½

    I originally watched this at a film festival in 2008; but a friend's recent mention of his reaction to another film from that same year, "Religulous," reminded me that this was a remarkable (and superior) companion piece to that Larry Charles/Bill Maher film. My review at the time:

    I had only known Julia Sweeney from her stint on "Saturday Night Live" and the terrible film It's Pat. So I had no idea that she had a one-woman show where she struggles with her religious identity (apparently a previous show of hers on this subject, God Said Ha!, was a festival prize winner in 1998). This beautifully produced video was simply 2 1/4 hours of Sweeney's routine: funny, informative, moving, amazing...where she went step by step through the process of her conversion from devout Catholicism to equally committed Atheism. Her search for the meaning of the universe started with a visit by two Mormon missionaries whose opening question: "Do you believe that God loves you" opened up a Pandora's box in her soul. She tells of embarking on an comprehensive quest through all the world's religions; and her rap is so trenchant, so well informed, so in sync with my own inchoate feelings on the subject of religion, that I felt like jumping up and clapping by the end...and sure enough the audience actually did break into spontaneous applause.

  • Frozen II

    Frozen II

    ★★

    A sequel of such mediocrity that it almost defies understanding. Sure, the Disney animation machine still functions at the top level artistically. But the lame story featuring sister princesses, and the insipid song score (no way comparing to the songs in the original) could only appeal to a starry-eyed tweener girl. It doesn't matter, of course. Disney is minting box office money from its captive audience. But I absolutely will not be suckered into watching Frozen III.

  • The Two Popes

    The Two Popes

    ★★★★

    I'll be honest: religion and the Vatican don't interest me very much and I don't even know how to recognize a Benedict from a Francis in real life. However, this rather intimate film about the two contemporary Popes and their elections and fraternal relationship over time did pique my interest. Certainly, any film that features such distinguished and committed actors as Anthony Hopkins and Jonathan Pryce would be worth a look. But the intelligent script, immaculate production, and fine direction sealed the deal for me.

  • Breakthrough

    Breakthrough

    ★★½

    In this "based on a true story" film, John, a 14-year old high-school basketball player, fell through pond ice and was underwater for 15 minutes before being rescued with no pulse and not breathing. John had been adopted from Guatemala by a devoutly Christian couple, the Smiths of St. Louis. The film tells the story of his struggle to live, aided by the prayers of his mother, his unconventional pastor and the entire community.

    I am a thoroughly committed agnostic (a little too circumspect to come out fully as atheist). So I watched this film filled with reservations, disbelieving in unexplained, so-called miracles. Nevertheless, the film was so well directed, the actors so committed and convincing (especially Chrissy Metz as the mother and Topher Grace as the pastor), that I was moved to tears despite my desperate attempt to remain skeptical. OK, I know that I'm a sucker for emotional manipulation; but I kinda felt good being manipulated by this film. So I gave it 2 1/2 stars, which could have gone a full point either way depending on my mood on the day I watched this...apparently yesterday I was somewhat forgiving and charitable.

  • Toy Story 4

    Toy Story 4

    ★★★½

    Andy is long grown and away at college; but his childhood toys (some no longer needed and sent to the 2nd hand store) now belong to his young sister, Bonnie, who spends her first day in kindergarten making a beloved (and quirky) personal toy out of a spork from the garbage. Many adventures among the humanized toys ensue. As usual for this series, the vocal acting is superb (I mean, Tom Hanks? Seriously, could any actor give earnest kindness better than Tom Hanks as the rag doll sheriff, Woody?) The 3D Pixar animation is, as usual, perfection. I'm definitely not a kid; but this adventure story is just too clever and fun not to appreciate and enjoy.

  • Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker

    Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker

    ★★★

    As space operas go, this film was sufficiently bombastic to make a big screen viewing worthwhile. But, honestly, if one has only a passing interest in the Star Wars universe (even having seen all 9+ of the films), is one likely to be thrilled by this film? Maybe it isn't the worst of the bunch; but it is still overlong, overly predictable, and mostly underwhelming...at least until the final scenes provide some resolution to the entire Jedi vs. Sith war to control the universe.

    And just a note: synthesizing Carrie Fisher's voice didn't quite work, sounding canned and slightly echoey. It's clear that the state of the art visual re-creation of a deceased actor is now a done deal. But work still needs to be done with the vocal quality and acting.

  • Maleficent: Mistress of Evil

    Maleficent: Mistress of Evil

    ★★★

    This high-gloss sequel is a Disneyfied half-animation, half-live action moral fable pitting humans against a coalition of witches and fairies in a typical medieval castle town. The animation and special f/x are spectacular, a triumph of artistry and production design. However, the story was one fairy tale cliché after another, stretched out to interminable length. However, Michelle Pfeiffer, dressed to the tits in the pearls and the raiments of the human Queen, was a memorable villain, well matched to Angelina Jolie's good/evil witch. And despite my reservations, I actually enjoyed the spectacle.