2014 SIFF FILMS PREVIOUSLY WATCHED & REVIEWED
All reviews based on 5 stars best

Age of Uprising: The Legend of Michael Kohlhaas   ★★½

 I had seen Volker Schlöndorff's previous version of this story, so the outlines of the narrative were familiar to me. It takes place in a rather austere part of France in the 16th Century, where a trader/landowner (played by the indominable Mads Mikkelsen) is cheated by a spoiled young baron, and foments a peasant's revolt to right the wrongs done to him. This is totally Mikkelsen's film, with his craggy face and wind swept mane of hair, and his character's quiet rectitude. But some of the smaller roles were well cast, especially favorites of mine, David Kroll and Denis Levant as concerned clerics. The film has little dialogue and much galloping around on horseback. The wide-screen cinematography is strikingly beautiful, taking full advantage of the authenticity of the setting. It has an intimate epic feel, somewhat reminiscent of Dreyers Passion of Joan of Arc; but frankly also felt too long with subtle issues that were confusingly presented.


Borgman   
★★★½

A mysterious cult infiltrates an upper-middle class family in this enigmatic satire which is obviously metaphorical...but a metaphor for what? Like the equally strange Greek film Dogtooth, which this film resembles, the innate meaning probably doesn't matter. In any case, it's a savage film, one that takes no prisoners. It is gorgeously shot and viscerally affecting; but I can't help feeling that the emperor has no clothes.


Burning Bush    ★★★★

After the Russians occupied Czechoslovakia in 1968, a committed student named Jan Palach immolated himself in full public view in Prague's Wencelas Square, martyring himself in the cause of freedom. This lengthy film is adapted from an HBO Central European mini-series directed by Agnieszka Holland. It centers on Palach's family and their attempts to use the legal system to counter the State's slander of his deed. This is a true story which needs to be remembered; and this film does a fine job of showing how the authorities manipulated the justice system and coerced people into acting disreputably by finding and using their weaknesses.

I had never heard of Palach before; but I was mesmerized by the repercussions of his act. This legal thriller managed to maintain its suspense and fascinating story over the entire 3 1/2 plus hours, without intermission. This wasn't a sumptuous production, rather an intimate people story of broad scope. If anything, I wish it had been even longer and painted the story with a broader brush.


The Butterfly’s Dream    ★★★★

In 1941 all the able bodied men in one area of Turkey were conscripted to work in the coal mines. The film opens with a large-scale B&W re-creation of the horrendous scene of chained men going to work underground. But that is prologue. As the screen turns to color, we're introduced to two young men in their early 20's. Both are aspiring impoverished poets; and both have tuberculosis. The film covers two years of these real-life men...their mutual love for an unobtainable girl from a rich family, their passion for life, their obscure output of poems. The cinematography and production is gorgeous. The lead actor, Kivanç Tatlitug has charisma to burn. The film was slow to establish its characters and plot; but by the end I found myself enormously moved by the tragic plight of these obscure poets.

Class Enemy    ★★★½

A substitute German teacher, quiet, earnest, unlikable, is introduced to a high-school class in a permissive, progressive school in contemporary Slovenia. An incident occurs which shakes up the class and they band together, at least most of the class, against the teacher. This is a metaphor for modern society; but it is also a riveting people story. It's amazing how many of the students become vivid personalities. As an adult, I've never really engaged with teenage kids, let alone grappled with school politics. But this film got to me.

The Disciple    ★★★★½

The setting is an isolated island lighthouse, in the early years of the 20th Century. The lighthouse keeper is a tyrant, a head of family who emotionally and physically abuses his wife and 13-year old son. Even his favorite young daughter doesn't escape his ire. Into this emotional powder keg comes a 13-year old orphan boy who is assigned as lighthouse apprentice against the father's will. What ensues is a raw and powerful Scandinavian family drama worthy of a Strindberg. It's also gorgeous to look at, taking full advantage of the sea and the sparse island landscape. The acting ensemble is flawless, especially the father (Niklas Groundstroem) and the two boys (Patrik Kumpulainen as the son, Erik Lönngren as the orphan.) I was enthralled and in suspense the entire film.

Four Corners    ★★½

The film takes place in the impoverished ghettos of Capetown, where several boys are missing, possibly victims of a serial killer. The area is part of a gang war between the 28's and the 26's, directly correlated to the American gangs, Bloods and the Crips, except even more violent; and the main character, a 28 general, has just been released from 13 years of prison. He is determined to quit the gang, settle down and find his 13-year old son, who has no knowledge of his father. The film is somewhat confusing as to motivations and quite disturbingly violent. This is an undoubtedly realistic slice of life; but one that I would just as soon have not experienced.


Free Range – Ballad on Approving of the World  

A young man is fired by his pregnant girlfriend's father for writing an embarrassing review of Malick's Tree of Life. That starts him on a downward spiral of existential angst. Rarely has a film seemed so artily pretentious, with long scenes of nothing happening mixed in with English language pop ballads that were just too on the nose. Maybe the ironic detachment will appeal to some; but for me it was deadly boring.

Gabrielle     ★★★½

Gabrielle Marion-Rivard is a real-life woman with Williams Syndrome, a genetic abnormality similar to but rarer and different from Down Syndrome. She has a bubbling personality and a musical gift. This is a fiction film, however, the story of such a 22-year old girl taking part in a musical choir which is rehearsing to perform at a rock concert backing Quebec poet/singer Robert Charlebois. The fictional Gabrielle falls in love with Martin, a fellow choir member (a wonderful performance by actor Alexandre Landry who perfectly portrays his high-functioning mental disability.) But much stands in the way of this budding romance. This is an off-kilter romantic drama which mostly works because the casting is so perfect.

Gerontophilia     ★★★½

This film is a total departure for a Bruce LaBruce film. 18-year old Lake (the preternaturally cute French Canadian actor Pier-Gabriel Lajoie) discovers that he has a fetish for elderly men while giving mouth-to-mouth resuscitation to a drowning senior citizen in his job as a lifeguard. He takes a job in an assisted living facility where he is, to say the least, happy as a clam. At the facility, he meets a lively octogenarian "queen" (Walter Border), and a sweet affair ensues.

In its way, this film is just as shocking and iconoclastic as previous films by the film maker. However, here he demonstrates a deft touch for romance and PG rated action. Somehow this unlikely relationship feels realistic, and a lot of the credit goes to the two actors who are totally charming and real. Think of a gay version of Harold & Maud with sex, and you come close to what this film is about. I've never really gotten into one of LaBruce's transgressive films before; but this is one movie that made *me* feel good.


Grand Central     ★★

"Love in the time of nuclear plant radiation". Tahar Rahim cements his reputation as France's new leading man, even if he looks like a scared and confused rabbit in most of this film. He has an illicit affair with Léa Seydoux, who looks fetching naked, but has never been more inert as an actress. They work at the looming Grand Central Nuclear Plant in the Loire Valley. The nuclear plant seen from the point of view of the lowest of maintenance workers, constantly exposed to dangerous radiation for the money, is a fascinating setting. But for a tawdry romance which is about as cliché as they come? Some talented actors wasted here (Olivier Gourmet! Denis Ménochet! Johan Libéreau!). But the inert menace of Grand Central is the real star of the film. And then there's that irresolute, confusing ending which left me feeling I wanted my money back (even though the screening was free.)

The Grand Seduction    ★★★

This is an English language remake of the 2003 French Canadian film Seducing Dr. Lewis, about a small town needing to acquire a doctor and willing to go to any length to persuade one to stay. In this case the young prospective doctor is played by Taylor Kitsch (whose career definitely needs a boost), and the town mayor by the wonderful Brendon Gleeson. The current film is funny and heartfelt. But my enjoyment was tempered a bit by the realization that I had seen all this before. I'm never quite sure why an English remake of a foreign language film is necessary, especially one that was a one-note, small town, shaggy-dog story to begin with. But Don McKellar's deft direction and the actors here were an improvement over the original.

Hotell     ★★★½

A young Swedish woman delivers a severely brain damaged son after a difficult childbirth. She falls into a heavy postpartum depression, and joins a therapy group with other depressives. Five of the group decide to "get away from it all" by checking into a nearby hotel cut off from the world. Only they can't escape themselves. That's the set-up for this interesting psychological character study. The characters are vivid and interesting. Their acting out their traumas rang true, even as it became difficult to watch. The film fails if the actors aren't convincing in their roles; and the film doesn't disappoint here. Especially notable was Alicia Vikander as the bereaved young mother. This is an intense drama; but ultimately a satisfying one.

The Keeper of Lost Causes    ★★★★

This is a crime thriller, adapted from the first of a series of novels called "Department Q" by Danish writer Jussi Adler-Olsen. The current story is very reminiscent of "The Silence of the Lambs;" but with a Scandinavian, technocratic edge to it. It stars a favorite actor of mine, Nikolaj Lie Kaas, as police inspector Karl Morck, who with his Arab assistant Assad have been sidelined out of homicide to run a cold case department. Morck is stubborn, and disobeys orders in order to deal with a five-year old cold case suicide that he is certain had been bungled by the police at the time. Of course the outcome of films like this are rarely unexpected. The tale is all in the telling. And this film is one terrific thriller, clever, suspenseful and drenched with atmosphere, which left me longing to see more of Inspector Morck (and read the books.)

I since have read the first four books of this series, and all I can say is that I hope that all four are made into films and exported to the U.S. market. 

Longwave     ★★

A Swiss radio team travels to Portugal during the 1974 "Carnation Revolution," military coup which overthrew the country's dictatorship. That's the set-up for a mostly unfunny fish-out-of-water comedy where most of the humor comes from one elderly correspondent with mild dementia massacring the Portuguese language (something that doesn't translate well into subtitles.) The film tries to be funny and also relevant, but mostly fails at both.

Mystery Road    ★★★

On a sparsely traveled highway in the Australian outback a trucker discovers a murdered Aborigine girl. The case is given to an out-of-favor indigenous cop; and it turns out this murder is only the tip of an iceberg of corruption and drug trafficking. The plot develops confusingly...several characters become vital to the case without much set-up. Or maybe I just lost concentration because of the slow pace and paucity of action until the final (unbelievable) shoot-out on a bluff overlooking Mystery Road. The film had atmosphere and interesting characters; but failed to present a coherent mystery story.

Not My Type    ★★★½

One can count on Belgian director Lucas Belvaux to deliver a film of uncommon sensibility no matter what the genre. Here he is doing the bitter-sweet romantic dramady genre about as well as it can be done. It's the story of Clément, a Parisian philosophy teacher and author who has commitment issues. He has been exiled for a year working as a teacher in a small provincial town; and there he meets a vivacious blonde woman named Jennifer, a single mother who cuts hair and is every bit the hick that he abhors. But there's this undeniable mutual attraction...

It's no accident that her name is Jennifer (pronounced with an English "J". ) Her hero is plucky Jennifer Anniston (and of course the professor has never heard of that actress.) Along with her best buds from work, Jennifer does disco karaoke...and she's really good, in an enthusiastic amateur fashion. As portrayed by lovely Émilie Dequenne, she's a fireball of enthusiasm, a ray of light.

Handsome, 30-ish actor Löic Corbery plays stalwart Clément...and he's quite good here. I don't think I've ever seen him in a film before; but I expect this to lead to other film roles. The film is notable for its resolute anti-Hollywood take on the rom-com genre. However, maybe there's a good reason for the traditional Hollywood ending, since I was prepared to rank this film much higher until the closing scenes. Also, despite holding my interest throughout, the film could use a little judicious pruning. At two hours, it seems a little padded. Still, the superb central performances and the smart script make this a film to watch for.


Of Horses and Men     ★★★

The film takes place presumably present day in a rural valley where the inhabitants are all involved with raising and handling horses. In a series of connected vignettes introduced by action being reflected in various horse's eyes, we experience a variety of tragi-comic stories, which show the symbiotic connection between horse and man in this isolated environment. The scenery is stunning, the sound mix, the cinematography outstanding. But I have to say the subject matter left me questioning the psychology of these characters. I was left with the impression that I had watched an affectionate satire that went over my head.

One Chance      ★★½

Overweight, schlubby operatic tenor Paul Potts actually did enter and win the first season of Simon Cowell's tv show "Britain's Got Talent." This somewhat involving biopic explains how he did it despite everything and the kitchen sink being thrown against him. Or so the screenplay would have us believe. Even more than the usual up-from-nothing-to-the-top-of-the-world story of pluck and talent, this one stirs the heartstrings. Predictable, yes; but sometimes true life really does play like pulp fiction. I cried "Uncle" and enjoyed the film despite myself.

A Place in Heaven ★★★★

A daring and profane Israeli officer nicknamed Bambi, during one of the early wars against the neighboring countries returns from battle and sells his "place in heaven" to the religious cook in return for a month of scrambled eggs. That is the jump-off point of a forty-year saga of Israel's secular and religious history through the tale of the rise and fall of this officer and his relationship with his Yemenite wife, and especially his son who grows up in revolt against everything his father stands for.

This is a powerful film which presents its father/son story with a kind of Old Testament savagery, something of Isaac and Jacob, or David and Absalom. Except this is in the realistic milieu of contemporary Israel. Director Yossi Madmon has an incredible eye for interesting compositions and a sure hand with his actors. He deftly combines the intimate family story within the sweep of real historical events; and makes the innate religious contradictions within Israeli society come alive as few films ever have. I was impressed by this film, by its scope and its emotional wallop.


Salvation Army     ★½


The place, Casablanca, Morocco late 20th century. 15-year old Abdella is growing up secretly gay in a large strife-torn family. He encounters older men and is exploited sexually (although it isn't clear whether he is doing it for money or just part of his passive nature.) After an uneventful trip to the seashore with his two brothers, the film shifts 10 years into the future where Abdella is now an impoverished exchange student wandering the streets of Geneva, Switzerland and moving into a Salvation Army hostel.

That's about it for story. Apparently the film is somewhat autobiographical...the director Abdella Taïa scandalously came out in 2007. The film does present an interesting aspect of what a gay Arab boy goes through in an oppressive society of shame and transgressive homosexuality. But despite looking authentic, the film just failed to deliver anything more than a moody character study. And for all that, the main character remained a cypher throughout the entire film.


Tom at the Farm     ★★★★

Tom, a young ad-man from Montreal fetchingly played by director Dolan, travels to the farm where his recently deceased lover, Guillaume, grew up. He's there to attend the funeral; but he encounters an unexpectedly weird family: Agathe, distraught, clueless mother (another of Dolan's remarkable mother figures played here by Lisa Roy). And previously unknown to Tom, the menacing brother, Francis, an imposing performance by Pierre-Yves Cardinal. Gradually over the course of the film, Tom infers his lover's back story, which is never explicitly one of abuse, but explains why Guillaume fled the farm at age 16, leaving his mother clueless about his sexuality.

Xavier Dolan is working from a play by Michel Marc Bouchard. I think this is the first time the former wunderkind has adapted someone else's work. I know nothing of the original play; but Dolan has obviously opened it up fairly successfully. And it certainly fits in with the director's previous oeuvre exploring dysfunctional family dynamics from the gay son's point of view. In my humble opinion, Dolan is the most interesting young director working in film today. And in this film he proves his mettle as an actor, with his most subtle portrayal yet of a character's strong moral backbone hidden behind a fey facade.


Touch of the Light    ★★★★

Huang Yu-siang is apparently a real-life blind piano prodigy from Taiwan. In this film he plays himself as a young man starting college, with all the problems that a blind person would have in such a normalized situation. That Siang (the character and actor) is quiet, friendly and super talented helps. The rather formulaic biopic story has him falling for a girl for her nice voice, who works in a fast food delivery place and aspires to be a dancer. OK, this all sounds really lame; but for some reason the film works. Part of it has to do with Huang's personality itself, where innate goodness shines through in every frame. Another factor is his co-star, the Eurasian actress Sandrine Pinna, who may not be a convincing dancer (every shot is done in close-up and we never actually see her in full body movement); but she is a lively and interesting actress. And I also have to give credit to first-time director Chang, who brings just the right amount of pizzazz to this old fashioned tale, with artful shots and fine montages. The sum total is an utterly charming musical romance. Who'd a thunk it.

Walesa. Man of Hope.    ★★★

This is a straightforward biopic of Lech Walesa from about 1970 through 1989 as he came to lead "Solidarity" and underwent various trials and tribulations on the way. The story is framed as part of an interview of Walesa by famed journalist Oriana Fallaci, which is a clunky narrative device, but works well enough. The film deftly combines B&W news footage with the re-created material. Robert Wieckiewicz made a convincing Walesa, looking the part. However, for all the film's glossy production values, it's hard to believe that this was made by the same filmmaker who made Man of Iron. This film confulingly jumps around the time line, and is just too episodic for an audience unfamiliar with the historical events.